Jeep Storefront.jpg




Locals catering to Neighbors & Visitors to Plum Island

P.I. residents Dave and Carol Dempsey, along with nephew and business partner, Bill Adams,
add color and flavor to Northern Blvd with the opening of Plum Island Kitchen. Formerly “PJ’s”

and “Plum Crazy”, P.I. Kitchen is primarily a grab-n-go restaurant with home cooked entrees to go, and self serve coffee bar. Our specialty pizzas, sandwiches and breakfast treats compliment our fellow island businesses. Specialty Thai food and Tuckaway Tavern meats and poultry are already favorites. Boxed lunches and ice cream are available during the warmer months. Bagged ice and propane are a convenient stop. Unique gifts from local artists are on display and available for sale.

OUR MISSION is simple. Offer quality food and service and have fun doing it!
                      Stop in and experience island hospitality at its finest.